My Dirtiest Fantasy is represented by 5 videos in the TubeFist - Gay Fisting Tube archive. The collection begins with Two Tops Fist Fuck James Oakleigh from March 10, 2019 and continues through Jimeno’s Extreme Fisting Debut: A Twink’s BDSM Awakening, added on March 23, 2026. Performers found across these videos include Caruso Rainbow, Daniel Karrington, David Cameron, James Oakleigh, Jimeno, Liam Holland, Nico Vegas and Ron Negba.